No punchline here, because it’s not a joke.
A middle school in Fairfax County, Virginia has banned all physical contact.
That’s right, ALL PHYSICAL CONTACT!
That means no hugging, no kissing, no handshakes, no high-fives, no group huddles, no hand-holding, no pats on the back, no bloody knuckles, and no poking. Did I forget something?
Why you ask? Well, let’s take a look…
According to the school officials at Kilmer Middle High School in Vienna, the ban “helps keep crowded hallways and lunchrooms safe and orderly, and ensures that all students are comfortable.”
No, it’ll teach kids that physical contact is frowned upon. What happened to raising kids to be normal?
If you tell kids that they can’t show affection physically, it’ll end with them either hiding their emotions, exhibiting them in private, or considering physical contact as a negative characteristic.
Now I’m not a psychologist, nor do I have any scientific facts to confirm my thoughts. Nevertheless, I do have common sense on board with me.
Teenage years are possibly the most important years of a child’s life, so restricting them from doing things which are completely normal and healthy in adult life might not be such a good idea.
So let’s look at the possible implications of a no contact ban on middle school kids.
Hand shaking
Hand shaking is in integral part of working life. Not just then, but also all through their social life.
Displays of Affection
I understand not wanting middle schoolers to go around at school making out and kissing. But middle schoolers are at the age where they are getting curious about relationships and affection, so banning such trivialities as hugging and holding hands is just going to make the kids more likely to actually act upon their new-found feelings. You remember back when you were small, and were told not to do something? What did you do? Yeah, you did it. Because you were curious.
Group Huddles, High-Fives, Pats On The Back
All three of these things are very normal behavior. And wait, don’t they all appear in sports? Come to think of it, so does hugging. And shaking hands with the opposing team after the game. I thought schools embraced sports. Wait a minute, don’t sports have a lot of physical conduct? Ok, ban sports while you’re at it, why don’t you…
Deborah Hernandez, Kilmer’s principal said that the rule makes sense in a school that was built for 850 students but houses 1,100. She said that students should have their personal space protected and that many lack the maturity to understand what is acceptable or welcome.
“students should have their personal space protected and that many lack the maturity to understand what is acceptable or welcome” Great, let’s downplay their intelligence while we’re at it, why don’t we? School is a place to learn, not just academics, but also about social interaction. It does no good banning them from doing something and then saying that they don’t understand what is right or wrong.
Here’s a thought: teach the kids what is the correct way to behave, instead of banning everything.
The Washington Post had an article on the school rule, highlighting how a seventh grader broke the rules by getting out of his assigned lunch room seat, sitting down next to his girlfriend, and putting his arm around her. Read it here.
Which brings me to my closing thought… Assigned lunch room seating?!
Apparently, physical contact is not the only thing the school board considers to have negative outcomes. Social interaction seems to threatened as well. Assigning lunch room seating is getting close to ludicrous.
Socializing is as important of an aspect of school life as say math or chemistry, maybe even more important. You aren’t allowed to socialize during class, which leaves you with recesses and lunch. Being assigned a seat, most likely next to someone the school randomly picked, instead of your closest friends, trumps the possibility of hanging out with you friends.
Sure, I can understand that the school officials wish to keep the cafeteria from turning into chaos, but too many rules is never good.
What do you think? Should schools be allowed to enforce these kinds of rules on kids? Or has it gone too far? If you have any personal stories of similar stupid rules from school, share your experiences in the comments section below.
Sources:
Washington Post (via Digg)










Recent Comments